Coudersport Music Teacher Charged with Murder after Shooting Ex-wife in Church

Greg Eldred, Coudersport School District music teacher and alleged shooter

COUDERSPORT – Gregory Lynn Eldred, a music teacher at Coudersport Elementary School, has been charged by State Police in Coudersport with First and Third Degree Murder, as well as several misdemeanor charges.

Eldred was arrested early this afternoon after he allegedly walked into the First United Presbyterian Church along North Main and 4th Street and shot his ex-wife, Darlene Sitler, a long-time music teacher at Northern Potter High School in Ulysses.

Sitler, who spent many hours tending to her church’s landscaping, also served as the church’s organist. She was a music teacher at Northern Potter for over 30 years. She was 53 years old.

Eldred has been a music teacher at Coudersport for at least 25 years. A U.S. Army Veteran, Eldred performed with the Army Band of NYC before earning a Bachelor of Science degree in Music Education from Indiana University of Pennsylvania.

Greg Eldred. Photo from Southern Tier Symphony

According to the Coudersport Elementary School website, “He is currently principal clarinet for the Southern Tier Symphony, Olean Community Orchestra and Wellsville Performing Arts Orchestra and plays saxophone in several community ensembles.  Mr. Eldred resides with his cat in Coudersport.  In his spare time he enjoys archery hunting, rifle hunting and golf.”

In addition to one count of First Degree Murder and one count of Third Degree Murder, 52-year-old Eldred has been charged with Simple Assault(M1), Recklessly Endangering Another Person(M2) and Terroristic Threats(M1).

Eldred, who was arraigned before District Judge Delores Weiss at 11:00 pm this evening, was denied bail and remanded to the Potter County jail.

A Preliminary Hearing has been scheduled for 1:00 pm on December 12 at District Judge Annette Easton’s office. The case is being prosecuted by District Attorney Andy Watson. Eldred is represented by Spencer Gleason, of Wellsboro.

Potter County Coroner Kevin Dusenbury, Sr. pronounced the victim dead at 12:15 pm this afternoon. State Police say they were assisted at the scene by Potter County District Attorney Andy Waston, Austin Police, Coudersport Police, Sweden Township Police, PSP Emporium, PSP Montoursville and Coudersport Volunteer Fire and Ambulance.


Scene outside shooting at First Presbyterian Church

Scene after shooting at Presbyterian Church

Save pagePDF pageEmail pagePrint page


  1. Lexikay515 says:

    Woah 😮 Lots of people are saying that it was an accident.. But I say that its not since he shot and killed his own x wife.. I heard he was looking at bad stuff so he got fired and thought his wife told but it was a few students… 😮

Trackbacks for this post

  1. […] Coudersport Fire Called for HazmatCoudersport Music Teacher Charged with Murder after Shooting Ex-wife in Church […]

  2. […] News Report. Share this:TwitterFacebookTumblrLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted in Domestic Violence, Murder and tagged Associated Press, Church service, Coudersport Pennsylvania, Darlene Sitler, Eldred, Elementary school, Gregory Eldred, murder, Pittsburgh, Presbyterianism on December 3, 2012 by bugbrennan. […]

Leave a Comment